Start with one brief
Give each agency the same roles, numbers, destination, pay, timeline, test requirements and replacement expectations. Ask them to respond in your format. If you let each supplier define the scope, you will be comparing different services rather than different prices.
A comparison sheet
| Line | Agency A | Agency B |
|---|---|---|
| Registration verified | Yes or no | Yes or no |
| Service fee per worker | Amount | Amount |
| Trade test included | Details | Details |
| Medical and visa handling | Included or extra | Included or extra |
| Worker charges | Stated amount | Stated amount |
| Replacement terms | Period and cost | Period and cost |
| Shortlist timing | Commitment | Commitment |
Questions that expose hidden assumptions
Before final comparison, send every bidder the same follow-up list. How many candidates will be presented for each post? Who pays for test venues, materials and assessors? Does the fee apply when a selected candidate withdraws? What happens if your permit is delayed? Are visa stamping, travel booking and airport assistance included? Which costs vary with exchange rates? Are taxes shown separately?
Ask each agency to state assumptions in writing. One may assume candidates travel to a single city, while another includes local screening in several states. One may include only one replacement, another may charge the full cost again. These differences usually explain more than the headline figure.
Then calculate the expected cost of a successful arrival, including likely withdrawals and replacements. This is a more useful basis for choosing than the amount printed against “service charge per worker”.
Keep your comparison and the reasons for your choice on file. If a client, auditor or new manager later asks why a supplier was appointed, you can show that licence checks, worker charges, test quality and commercial terms were all considered. The same record also makes the next tender much quicker, because the questions and scoring already exist.
Why a low quote deserves questions
An unusually low or zero employer fee can reflect genuine efficiency, but it can also mean that candidates are funding the recruitment or that testing is thin. Ask how the agency earns its income on this job, and what each candidate will pay. A clear explanation is reassuring. Evasive answers tell you what you need to know.
Score what affects outcomes
- Evidence of experience in your trade and destination.
- Quality of their test method.
- Transparency about sub-agents.
- Responsiveness during the quotation stage.
- Willingness to accept audits and fair-recruitment terms.
- Clarity on what they cannot promise.
Run a small test
Where the order allows, ask finalists to present sample candidate files or organise a pilot test day. How they handle detail at this point is a good indicator of how they will perform later. Check references too, using contacts you can validate independently, and ask those clients what went wrong as well as what went right.
Questions employers ask
How many quotes should we seek?
Two to four verified agencies are usually enough to compare without overwhelming your team.
Should the cheapest compliant agency win?
Not automatically. Consider test quality, service and replacement risk, as a failed hire can cost more than the fee difference.
Can we negotiate?
Yes, ideally through volume, simpler processes or quick approvals, not by squeezing costs onto workers.
What if an agency will not itemise its quote?
Ask why. Some bundling is normal, but you still need to know what is included, what is extra and whether workers pay anything.
General information, reviewed 2026-11-19. Rules change and differ by country, so confirm the current position with the authority concerned or your legal adviser before acting.
Keep reading
Planning to hire from India?
Send the roles, numbers, destination and start date. We reply with a written scope, timeline and cost.
Send your requirement