Why letters are not enough
Small contractors may issue informal letters, and honest workers may have worked for firms that no longer exist. At the same time, certificates can be exaggerated or bought. Do not treat a neat letterhead as proof or a missing one as guilt. Look at the overall picture, and put most weight on what can be demonstrated.
Evidence you can combine
| Evidence | What it adds | Limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Experience letter | Employer, role and dates | May be informal or inflated |
| Payslips or bank credits | Shows payment over time | Private, so request with care |
| Provident fund records | May support formal employment | Not all workers are covered |
| Passport and visa stamps | Supports past overseas work | Does not prove the trade |
| Reference call | Gives direct feedback | Needs an independent number |
| Practical test | Shows current ability | Does not confirm past dates |
A proportionate approach by role
The depth of checking should match the risk. For a general helper, a reference call for a sample of candidates plus a practical assessment may be reasonable. For a crane operator, electrician, driver or caregiver, verify licences and recent experience more carefully, since mistakes can seriously harm people. For supervisors, speak to someone who actually saw the person lead a crew.
Write this down as a simple matrix so that decisions are not improvised. It should state which checks apply to each job family, who performs them and what happens when evidence is incomplete. This also protects candidates from arbitrary treatment.
If a recruiter is carrying out checks, ask for the evidence rather than a tick mark. Review a sample personally each month. If your own calls frequently produce different answers, stop and fix the process before more workers go forward.
Making a good reference call
- Obtain the candidate’s consent.
- Find the company’s number independently.
- Ask for the supervisor or HR department.
- Confirm dates, job title and work performed.
- Ask whether they would rehire and why.
- Note who you spoke to and when.
Questions that test the story
Ask about real details: the type of machine on the last site, how the crew was organised, which standards were used, what was difficult. For someone claiming Gulf experience, ask about the project type and daily work without treating a well-known company name as evidence. People who did the work usually answer naturally, even if their language is simple.
Handling gaps fairly
Many workers have gaps caused by family responsibilities, seasonal work or the end of a contract. Ask neutrally. Treat deliberate falsification differently from an informal or incomplete record, and state your rule in advance. Be careful with personal data, collecting only what the decision requires and keeping it secure.
Questions employers ask
What if a former employer has closed?
Look for pay records, former supervisors, project evidence and a stronger practical assessment. Record what could not be verified.
Can a recruiter do this for us?
Yes, but agree the method and ask for evidence. Sample some checks yourself so you know how well they are being done.
How much experience should we require?
Require only what the job needs. Inflated demands encourage inflated claims and can screen out capable workers.
Do we need the candidate’s consent?
You should be transparent and follow applicable privacy law. Asking for consent before contacting a former employer is good practice.
General information, reviewed 2026-11-19. Rules change and differ by country, so confirm the current position with the authority concerned or your legal adviser before acting.
Keep reading
Planning to hire from India?
Send the roles, numbers, destination and start date. We reply with a written scope, timeline and cost.
Send your requirement